“Back in my day, if you fell, you lost.”
Sharon Taylor was watching the replay of NCA when she turned to her daughter, Jessica Bugg, (below right) an Allstar insider for more than 15-years, originally from Kentucky's grass roots cheer country and currently coaching with Island Allstars in Jacksonville, Florida.
“I’m watching all these divisions and I’m seeing teams falling and winning.”
Jessica’s mom pretty much summed- up the thoughts of many this season.
While parents' (and coaches') concerns about discrepancies in scoring from competition to competition are nothing new, this season's coveted "Zero Club" or "You Hit!" buttons handed out in reward for a deduction-free routine have parents scratching their heads and talking (and much
more) on social media when teams do not win, some placing in the lower 25% of its divisions.
Granted, scoring has, and will continue to undergo changes (Did you know, as of this season, bobbles are no longer considered deduction-worthy? I didn't).
Industry leaders Melissa Hay, Nestor Dela Pena and Justin Carrier feel our pain.
"The scoring process is complicated," Melissa said (photo left).
"Just this past weekend at a competion in Puerto Rico, a parent came up to me and asked if I knew who won a division, and when I said 'No I don't, I'm only the building judge, I don't know the overall scores,' they looked at me with a really confused look on their face. Like, how could I be a judge and not know the score?"
In addition to being a judge of international competitions, Melissa's 23 years of cheerleading experience includes: 15 years of college coaching; she's a 2004 inductee into Who’s Who of College Coaching; 2006 Finalist National Coach of the Year; 2010 Finalist SITA College Coach of the Year; 2011 inductee College Cheer Coaching Hall of Fame; participated in the first STUNT Exhibition; coached first season College STUNT; AACCA Safety Certified; founder and owner of CheerXM1; Presenter at various national coaches' conferences; and is published as an expert cheer source in national magazines.
In her most parent-friendly explanation, Melissa says every routine is scrutinized by a tumbling judge, building judge and overall judge which critique each area accordingly and score to the grid. There is also a legalities judge and safety judge.
Deductions come into play with the safety judge.
"A team with no deductions doesn't mean they recieve the highest score," Melissa says. "They may not have had enough difficulty in their routine or their technqiue, for what they performed, was not clean enough to score in a higher range."
"In addition to the choreography and coaching, you need a certain amount of difficulty performed by the team to be in the high range," she continues.
Routines which score in the high range have to be techincally accurate with all skills as well as being very clean. The difficulty and technique scores are added together. Combined together, you get the overall skill score.
"What will happen is there is a routine that has zero falls, but is slow paced to make it a clean routine but without enough difficulty, compared to other teams," Melissa continued. "Or take out difficulty; an elite or difficult skill, to hit a routine but lowers the difficulty score. Not enough elements (in the routine) to score higher. But another team can have a higher difficulty all around."
"So in that regard, teams are falling and winning."
If you are looking for Allstar royalty, you have to include Nestor Dela Pena. Nestor, and his Miami Elite teammates have the distinction of being "first in first place" winning the inaugural USASF Worlds in 2004 (and back-to-back titles to boot, winning again in 2005) setting the mark in the always, very elite Large Coed Level 5 division.
In the last 22 years, Nestor has been: gym owner (Miami Elite); coach (Miami Elite, Elite Cheer, Broward Elite in Florida and Cheer Force in California); choreographer (20 years); 14 years as a national judge; multiple presenter at USASF national conferences; is USASF Safety Certified in Levels 1-5; AACCA Safety Certified; a 2011 inductee into the USASF’s Who’s Who of All Star Cheer Coaches; and in 2012, nominee for Small Gym of the Year/Inside Cheerleading Magazine.
Last year Nestor opened Allstar Cheer Consultants (Melissa Hay is also the marketing and administrative director) which provides many services to gyms all around the country, including critiquing (pre-judging) routines by reviewing videos and on-site visits to help teams with technique and tweaking routines to be in the best “judgeability” as possible. It's his judge's eye that we are interested in for this article and Nestor was gracious with his time in this special Q&A:
CheerMAD: As a judge, what is the biggest surprise you’ve seen?
Nestor: There’s been a great leap in the level of competition this year compared to last year. It feels like everyone took a huge step-up in technique and creativity. The difference between teams is mostly in technique, everybody is doing the same skills, the cleaner ones are winning.
Having said that, my surprise is, teams are competing really difficult elements without mastering those elements, or not cleaning up the technique, and are still expecting to win.